Anti-Immigrant Laws May Begin To Proliferate, Again

Already the ripples of the U.S. Supreme Court decision on immigration that I spoke about recently are starting to be felt. Already the wave of premature celebration over  piecemeal legal victories is growing.

Here’s what’s happened: The Supreme Court has decided that an Arizona law that revokes the state licenses of businesses that don’t comply with worker verification is legal. So Arizona may proceed to take operating licenses away from businesses that don’t comply with their state immigration laws.

In the wake of this decision the Justices of the Supreme Court have given new life to a controversial immigration law in a small town in Pennsylvania. In 2006 the town of Hazleton made headlines when it enacted deeply stringent laws that, according to,

would penalize landlords who rented to illegal immigrants, and employers who hired them.

A year later the law was blocked by a federal court after challenges by area Latino rights groups. In 2010 a U.S. Appeals Court upheld the block saying that immigration was the sole jurisdiction of the federal government. But now the Supreme Court has once again opened the door to the Hazleton law, specifically because of their recent decision in the Arizona law. They’ve ordered that the Hazleton statute be sent back to the Appeals Court for another review.

You can see where some of the the folks in Hazleton and the proponents of strict immigration measures would be giddy about this. They think they’ve been given a gift. They think the Supreme Court has given them the nod to proceed. But it may not be that cut-and-dry.

A judicial order of further review is not a reversal. The Supreme Court didn’t say the Hazleton law was good to go, they said the Appellate Court needed to take a second look. There’s a big difference. Witold “Vic” Walczak, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, told that

two out of three recent remands to the Third Circuit resulted in reaffirmations of the original rulings.

So it’s too soon for the anti-immigrant ilk to be making party plans. The Supreme Court merely wants the Hazleton law to be put to a newer test: Does it infringe on federal jurisdiction, given the parameters of the Arizona decision? Did the Hazleton fathers over-step their boundaries? It could be that the Hazleton law is being set up to be shot down twice and for all.

Regardless of which way the Appellate Court leans, it’ll speak volumes about the idea of America, what it means and what it is to be an American. This is what the entire immigration debate is about and has been about for generations.  This Hazelton remand is no different.

Follow Victor Landa on Twitter: @vlanda

[Photo by yeowatzup]


Subscribe today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Must Read

U.S. citizen detained overnight by ICE – they thought he was undocumented

Victor Landa July 6, 2017

By Victor Landa, NewsTaco (1.5 minute read)  This is startling news. Up until last night at a dinner conversation I believed that the idea that an American citizen would be […]

Willie Velásquez documentary is a lesson for Latinos on the importance of voting

NewsTaco May 9, 2017

*Why you should read this: Because today is Willie Velasquez day and a quick search of his name turned up no news stories. This piece, by Mercedes Olivera, is from […]

DIECIOCHO Podcast: Texas Rep. Rafael Anchia – Trump, Gerrymandering and Money

NewsTaco June 8, 2017

By Victor Landa, NewsTaco (1 minute read, 34 minute listen)  It’s safe to say that the just-ended Texas legislative session was the most acrimonious in memory. We can talk for […]

Ted Cruz gets an earful in McAllen for July 4

Victor Landa July 5, 2017

*I’m posting this because it was mostly Latinos, organizing, protesting, making their voices heard. Everyone needs to know that Latinos in deep South Texas are standing up. VL By Patrick […]

Pence will host White House Cinco de Mayo party

NewsTaco May 4, 2017

*Why you should read this: Because there’ll be no Cinco de Mayo celebration at the White House (I know, big deal – we’ll be spared the taco-bowl). VL By Hadas […]

Castro will not run for U.S. Senate

NewsTaco May 1, 2017

By Victor Laneda, NewsTaco (i.5 minute read)    Rep. Joaquin Castro (D-TX) says he will not be running for the U.S. Senate against Ted Cruz. Castro had promised to make […]

Vietnam War veteran fears he could be deported

Victor Landa July 7, 2017

*This Vietnam veteran, born in Mexico, was awarded two Purple Hearts and given U.S. citizenship after his service. He’s misplaced his documents and after paying $345 the government wants more […]

Henry Cisneros: Why Can’t Americans See Latinos Are Country’s ‘Saving Grace’?

Victor Landa

*Good question. I think it’s because we’re not the ones telling our story. We need to fight for our narrative. VL By Suzanne Gamboa, NBC News (1.5 minute read)  SAN […]