Is It Time for a New Voting Rights Act?

u._s._supreme_court_scotusVictor Landa, NewsTaco

For all of the anticipation leading up to the Voting Rights challenge at the U. S. Supreme Court there are a couple of things that bubbled to the surface and that are worth noting in it’s wake: Justice Scalia’s “racial entitlement” comment and the idea that maybe we’re better off with judicial creative destruction, where Section 5 is struck down to make room for a new, more comprehensive voting rights enforcement code.

On the first count, Scalia’s statement was unexpected but not uncharacteristic. He said Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA) amounted to a “perpetuation of racial entitlement.” Of course Scalia would say something like that, it’s not the first time he’s lifted his robe to let us see his stripes, so we shouldn’t be surprised. But reports from the chamber state there was an audible gasp at the statement. It’s one thing to think it, and to know Scalia thinks as he does, but it’s another to hear it so blatantly.

The remark didn’t go unnoticed. The New York Times reports:

That remark created the sharpest exchange of the morning, with Justice Sonia Sotomayor on the other end. “Do you think that the right to vote is a racial entitlement?” she later asked a lawyer challenging the law, with an edge in her voice that left little doubt she was responding to Justice Scalia’s statement. “Do you think that racial discrimination in voting has ended, that there is none anywhere?”

That leads me to the second item, the creative destruction.

At one point during the questioning Chief Justice Roberts asked if  “the citizens in the South are more racist than citizens in the North.” If truth be told, no, they’re not. Given the evidence of voting delays and disenfranchisement in the North, it’s possible to say that the North and the South are equal on this count. So from this point of view Section 5 of the VRA is antiquated and needs a makeover; it needs to be struck down to make room for a larger, more inclusive law that casts a wider enforcement net – not limited to only nine states and parts of others. Some call it a “modern voting rights act.”

A model of how this can be done is in the act itself. Section 3 of the VRA – a.k.a. the “pocket trigger” – gives federal courts the authority to place states and political subdivisions that have violated the Fourteenth or Fifteenth Amendments under preclearance. In other words, Section 3 is a way of putting bad actors under the scrutiny called for in Section 5. It’s also known as the bail-in clause and it’s been used a few times in the past.

For Latinos and Latino voters this is very important. As the Latino community grows and spreads there will be a need for a voting rights enforcement code that is more portable, for lack of a better word – a code that follows them as American citizens, across the country, and not as a minority group in selected states in the South.

Does that mean that we tear down the existing VRA and build a new one in its place?

That would have to come through congress, so, good luck floating a new Voting Rights Act through the swamp that’s become.

Maybe the clunky old 1965 version of the VRA is good enough for now, reauthorized as it has been over the years. And maybe we’ll have to rely on it as we figure out a better way to move forward. The threat, though, is that this latest challenge has put Section 5 in peril, Scalia’s statement is proof enough of that.

[Photo courtesy c-span]

Subscribe today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Must Read

How a harsh criticism turned ‘Coco’ into Pixar’s most uniquely made movie yet

Victor Landa November 17, 2017

Director Lee Unkrich was hot off the box office success and Oscar win for 2010’s “Toy Story 3” when he delved into making a movie that focused on the Mexican […]

Trump Administration Targets and then Mocks Immigrant with Prosthetic Leg

Victor Landa November 15, 2017

A 20-year-old undocumented immigrant with prosthetic leg and Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals status has been detained by federal immigration agents and held without charges for over a month, treated inhumanely […]

More Latinas are becoming teachers and reshaping our nation’s classrooms

Victor Landa November 29, 2017

The growth of the Latino population in the United States will have a lasting cultural and intellectual impact beyond the arts, food, and celebrations. More and more, Latinas are becoming […]

As Numbers Grow, Recognizing Generations Of Latino Veterans

Victor Landa November 10, 2017

As the nation honors its veterans, government officials point to the growing numbers of Latinos in the military, while Hispanic scholars and historians remind us of the generations of Latino […]

U.S Hispanic Chamber Leader Who Has Had Turbulent Relationship With Trump May Be Ousted

Victor Landa November 22, 2017

The US Hispanic Chamber of Commerce (USHCC) is moving behind the scenes to oust its prominent president Javier Palomarez over allegations that he misused the organization’s money for his personal […]

How Indie Latinx Comic Book Authors Are Capturing the Latinx Experience

Victor Landa November 13, 2017

Back in 2010, comics creator Javier Hernandez was walking around San Francisco with his friend Ricardo Padilla when he had an idea: Why don’t they build a comics convention focusing […]

Half of Latino Immigrant Characters on TV Are Portrayed as Criminals, Study Finds

Victor Landa November 1, 2017

Define American, the immigration nonprofit founded by Pulitzer-winning journalist Jose Antonio Vargas, has released its first-ever media reference guide for writers, directors, and producers concerning Latino immigrant characters. Immigrants and […]

Hispanic Caucus denies membership to Republican Carlos Curbelo

Victor Landa November 17, 2017

The Congressional Hispanic Caucus on Thursday denied Republican Rep. Carlos Curbelo his membership bid, the latest volley in a nasty dispute between the Florida lawmaker and some members of the […]